In this article, you will get the similarities and dissimilarities between these two renowned Brooks saddles. The saddle is better and more comfortable than I expected. This, the B17 Women’s Standard S, cushions your female bum throughout lengthy road tours and off-road jaunts. Brooks B17 is a viable choice for touring and trekking. That’s why you need to cushion your female bum during long road tours and off-road jaunts. The pictures tell a good bit of the story (L toR Berthoud Touring, Brooks B17 and Brooks Swift: The Bi7 is a few years old with about 7K miles on it. I have a Brooks B17 and would not trade it for anything after more than 5,000 miles. I have always heard these saddles were the most comfortable so I took the risk and IT WAS THE GREATEST CHOICE OF MY LIFE! The Flyer The Flyer has the same basic shape as the B17 but for extra comfort on rough roads, it is equipped with springs.. In fact, Company/product listings on this page DO NOT imply endorsement by the site operator. Incidently, they are all breaking in differently. I've heard great things about the leather B17, but I understand it requires a decent bit of upkeep as it is saddle and needs maintenance. Standard bike seat - Men's, Planet Bike 5022 Men's ARS Competition Anatomic Relief Saddle with Gel, Selle Anatomica X1 X Series WaterShed Black with Gunmetal Rivets, Best Electric Bike Kits to Convert Your Two-wheeler Into an E-bike, Best Bike GPS for Navigation During Bike Tours, Best Cycling Shoes to Level up Your Rides. The Terry Fly Ti will be more comfortable initially compared to the Brooks models. The B17 is our flagship model, ideal for long distance sports touring, trekking and mountain bike use. In this video I review the Brooks B17 Saddle. Final 2,500 Miles: Brooks B17 Test Just shy of halfway through my bike tour, I traded out the C17 for the classic leather B17 Standard . In general, Brooks B67 makes a better choice, considering that the price gap is not very big. Excellent, easily the most comfortable bike seat I've ever owned. It is just great! The honey leather seat is available along with tubular steel rivets or with hand-hammered copper rivets under the name of Flyer Special S. NOTE: Product prices, availability, ratings and save money information are accurate as of the date/time indicated on post time (as seen right bellow the tittle) and are subject to change. It is directly descending from the B66 Champion, first featured in the 1927 catalogue. In this post, we’ll compare both classic saddles so you can pick the right one. Both saddles have the same dimensions - the Flyer is more or less a B17 with springs. Only thing different is that this saddle's sprung. None of Brooks saddles are light, if you want light get a different saddle, if you want comfort in a saddle that can easily last 20 years then get a Brooks. It’s … There was varying opinions on the model to go for, but it appeared that the majority of touring enthusiasts opted for either the Flyer or the B17 (The Flyer is effectively a B17 with springs). Our best-selling model for over 100 years, the B17 is the ideal bicycle saddle for commuting, gravel, road and touring use. As with the B15, the B17 is handmade in England. I have found the most comfortable for me is a slight tilt up for the nose of the saddle. It's one of Brooks very best and was recently reproduced with copper rivets and copper rails, as well as black leather. Rivets – Ideal for Touring or Trekking – Wider Seat. It's less "plush" given the lack of springs, of course, but the B67's width gets in the way of my legs when riding in a sportier position. It's … Brooks B67 Vs B17 Saddle Comparisons. This model comes with the additional suspension granted by 2 rear springs. “Brooks” is a renowned name in the bicycle saddle industry, especially for making the vintage-style leather saddles. ­ All Rights Reserved. Brooks England made this bike seat wider than others in its sports classification for comfort and ease on extensive, multiday trips. In my view, all the other Brooks roadbike saddles (the B17 Narrow, the Team Pro, the Swift, and the Swallow) are too narrow for the majority cyclists who are likely to be reading this post. Brooks has been selling the B17 leather saddle continuously since the 1890s. It has been on the market for over 100 years, being featured in as early as the 1898 catalog . It is directly descending from the B66 Champion, first featured in the 1927 catalogue. The Brooks England B17 Bike Saddle has been cushioning bums on bikes since 1898. Don't let the fact that it is hard as rock out of the box fool you, it really is a superb seat! Two Rear Springs – Available with Tubular Steel or Hand Hammered Copper Gear Review: Brooks Flyer S. My first touring bicycle came with a Men’s Aged Brooks B17 saddle. I rode 60 miles on the first day and it was comfortable as expected. Brooks Champion Flyer Saddle user reviews : 4.5 out of 5 - 22 reviews. The Conquest (on the SJS site) seems to be the female equivalent of the Champion Flyer. I find the Champion Flyer very comfortable off-road. It has been on the market for over 100 years, being featured in as early as the 1898 catalog. The Flyer and its ladies model Flyer S are classically sprung saddles for long distance trekking and touring. The Flyer and its ladies model Flyer S are classically sprung saddles for long distance trekking and touring. This has been fashioned in celebration of Brooks' 150th anniversary. Leather moulds perfectly to individual shape like a comfortable shoe over time. Having the right bicycle seat on your bike can make all the difference. It seems to be getting increasingly comfortable. Which one is better suited to which specific types of riding and maintaining certain cycling positions? Do come in and take a seat. — Roy. Still, it is already very comfortable and will only get better with time. The information which appears on this site is subject to change at any time. Der beliebteste und meist verkaufte Sattel von Brooks ist der B17 Ledersattel, der bereits seit 1888 zu verkaufen ist. The Brooks Heritage Flyer Special Saddle combines the styling of the B17 with the suspension of two large steel springs for a clean retro look and added comfort. Along the course of this article, we shall be providing you with an in-depth analysis and describing the similarities and differences in-between these distinguished Brooks … I’ve found the springs on the Flyer to be … Any price, availability and save money information displayed on Amazon Site at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. One thing to bare in mind; Brooks saddles have less forward and backwards travel than most other saddles. But quality and style never age. The Flyer and its ladies model Flyer S are classically sprung saddles for long distance trekking and touring. The Flyer is nice, I weigh about 175, and I find the boinginess to be minimal. As with other Brooks saddles, the Imperial takes some bedding in, but it is noticeably more comfortable to begin with than a standard B17. I have both, the B17 on a 72 Raliegh Pro, the Flyer on a steel hardtail I built. Started good and is only getting better as it breaks in. More info, Copyright © 2020 www.bestadvisor.com. Great review of a great saddle! Length: 275mm Width: 175mm Height: 87mm Weight: 890g Register for Brooks Forever to extend the 2 year warranty to 10 years. Brooks Saddles Flyer S is a classically sprung saddle for long-distance trekking and also touring for females. I now have a Brooks on 3 out of 4 bikes. Brooks B17 Imperial for touring, Brooks Swallow for racing and Seller Anatomica on Audax and MTB bike. Brooks Champion Flyer Classic, Honey (B17 with springs) - 11046Same dimensions as the B17. A supremely comfortable saddle thanks to its flexible, hammock-like, performance that moves with every pedal stroke, the B17 is a bike seat designed for the 60° angled riding position. Brooks B17 vs. C17. My friend has the C17 Cambium, which I believe is rubber, and seems to like it. The springs do add a great deal of weight to the seat and thus to the bike overall, and it is noticeable when lifting the back end of the bike. On the other side, you can pick the B17 for comfort on long, multi-day rides. The saddle is very smooth/slick but a couple adjustments to the nose height/angle and I quit sliding forward. This saddle’s leather-based cover, chrome-plated steel rivets, as well as steel rails appear classy atop your two-wheeled steed–plus, the leather adjusts to your body shape just like leather boots satisfy your feet. I've now got about 2000 miles on it now, and I'll never ever run any other seat again. The Brooks England B17 Bike Saddle has been cushioning bums on bicycles since 1898. The decision is based on your needs. The Flyer model has springs for comfort and the B-17 does not. Sharing the same leather tops of the B17 models, they combine the comfort of these popular models with the extra suspension granted by two rear springs. Brooks Flyer Saddle The Flyer is a classically sprung saddle for long distance trekking and touring. This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors. The saddle seems to disappear under me when I ride it and I rarely notice or think about it on that bike, I take this as a good thing and that I am on the right track. Good luck! This involved almost daily adjustments to mostly saddle tilt. Damit hatten die ursprünglichen Entwerfer einen wahrhaft zeitlosen Fahrradsattel geschaffen – denn kaum ein anderes Teil irgendwo am Fahrrad kann sich damit rühmen, seit über einem Jahrhundert benutzt zu werden. Perhaps I … It is directly descending from the B66 Champion, first featured in the 1927 catalog. Except as expressly set forth in our Terms of Use, all representations and warranties regarding the information presented on this page are disclaimed. If you need extra Suspension from 2 rear springs, then you should choose Brooks Saddles Flyer. Everyone seems to prefer that as they seem to prefer ortlieb panniers. As it … This model comes with the additional suspension granted by 2 … I bought this saddle (actually a B17 Titanium) to go on my touring bike with the sole purpose of long miles. The weight penalty of the Flyer S over the similarly styled non-suspension B17 S is considerable, but if your route regularly takes in potholes and imperfections in the road, the Flyer’s suspension springs are surprisingly effective, ironing out the worst of the jarring, and giving a noticeably smoother ride, without any marked loss of power. Are you a woman biker? The springs really do help a lot. © 2020 by BikeIsFun.com is a participant of Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for website owners to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon (.com, .co.uk, .ca etc ), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), – Imported – Leather – Comfortable – Ladies – Classic, – Classically Sprung Saddle – Extra Suspension from But let me tell you I am a 5'2" female weighing in about 125 measley pounds and it only took 4 rides (roughly 50 miles) before it started feeling cushy!! These are in fact the same saddle, only the Flyer has springs and the B17 does not. Sharing the same leather tops of the B17 models, they combine the comfort of these popular models with the extra suspension granted by two rear springs. The Flyer and its ladies model Flyer S are classically sprung saddles for long distance trekking and touring. The B17 Saddle. The cutout in the Terry will help to take pressure off the body and adds some ventilation. I don't really miss the springs when not perfectly upright, anyhow, and the weight is a no-brainer. Sharing the same leather tops of the B17 models, they combine the comfort of these popular models with the extra suspension granted by two rear springs. Sharing the same leather tops of the B17 models, they combine the comfort of these popular models with the extra suspension granted by two rear springs. The scoring that appears on this site is determined by the site operator in its sole discretion, and should NOT be relied upon for accuracy purposes. Yes, you are special! Which one is better for which types of riding and cycling positions? The B17 works for a slight-to-moderate forward lean like the Brompton encourages for most riders. It is directly descending from the B66 Champion, first featured in the 1927 catalog. Once I hit about 300 miles, it was magic! Be sure to pick a seat that will fit both your body type and personal riding style.About Brooks - "Brooks England is steeped in history, a prestige brand that boasts almost 150 years of tradition and expertise. I don't have many miles on my Flyer yet, and it definitely isn't fully broken in yet. Brooks Saddles Flyer. It is directly descending from the B66 Champion, first featured in the 1927 catalogue. I have tested this saddle for over 10,000 Km now and this is what I have to say! It's only going to get better with each ride. The Flyer Special is a touring saddle with suspension springs for comfort and hand-hammered rivets for long-lasting durability, sharing the same leather top as the B17 model but with extra suspension and hand-hammered copper rivets to protect the leather over time. I went 1300 miles before a B17 became comfortable on one of my bikes. The B17 is our flagship model, ideal for long distance sports touring, trekking and mountain bike use. The Berthoud is now two years old with about 5k miles on it, and the Swift is fresh out of the box. It seems like the best choice of brand is hands down Brooks. So after 200 miles, I'm happy and will probably stick with it. They love it and it is very popular. Not mushy at all, but you can definetly feel it taking up the shock of big bumps. You might want to let your readers know that the Brooks Flyer is a B17 with springs. My first ride was 4 miles of pure comfort, and each subsequent one has gotten longer and are equally comfortable. Brooks Saddles Flyer S is a classically sprung saddle for long-distance trekking and also touring for females. As others have said the springs are stiff but they do smooth out the hard jolts to the posterior when you hit and unexpected pot hole. Even though not designed for a woman, I quickly (after about 200 miles) became used to the saddle, and continued to ride it for several thousand miles. Second B17 after the first bike and saddle were stolen, super comfortable for me, long touring rides, gets better with age. See also: Brooks B67 Vs B17. Please be advised that the operator of this site accepts advertising compensation from certain companies that appear on the site, and such compensation impacts the location and order in which the companies (and/or their products) are presented, and in some cases may also impact the scoring that is assigned to them. Read it's strength, weaknesses, find deals and pricing - mtbr.com Using the smooth seat and wearing shorts composed of man-made materials can result in a little too much movement in the saddle to the point of feeling slippery. The leather takes a long time to soften up. So far the saddle has been very comfortable and still looks great. The Flyer features bag loops to permit the use of a traditional English-style touring bag. Brooks B67 vs. Flyer. Handmade in England, Vegetable Tanned Leather, Vegetable Tanned Leather, Handmade in England, Double Rear Spring, Selle Italia Diva Gel Flow Women's Bicycle Saddle (Vanox Rails), Terry Butterfly Ti Gel+ Bicycle Saddle - 21024, Fizik Antares R3 K:ium Rails Road Bicycle Saddle, Fizik Antares VS Saddle with 7x9 Carbon Braided Rail, Black, Fizik Arione K:ium Rails Road Bicycle Saddle, Fizik Aliante Gamma K:ium Rails Road Bicycle Saddle with Team Logos, Fizik Aliante VS X Kium Saddle 2016 by Fizik, Planet Bike 5020 A.R.S. The Flyer is most appropriate for cyclists who set their handlebars about the same height as their saddles, or perhaps a bit higher. It is directly descending from the B66 Champion, first featured in the 1927 catalogue. I can feel it flex underneath me and provide some amount of cushion from the road, but not so much that it feels too squishy or robs me of pedaling energy. They provide 2 bestsellers and phenomenal saddles named Brooks B17 and Brooks Saddles Flyer. Brooks B67 can give you the ultimate comfort, especially for long sessions. The classic design of the Flyer S Saddle from Brooks Heritage Saddles features two rear springs that provide a smooth ride for long-distance touring on your bicycle. For long distance this is essential otherwise riding will be increasingly uncomfortable until riding becomes painful, removing the pleasure of the ride. It's important to buy a cover if you're going to be in you're going to be in wet conditions. It is simply amazing, 70 mile rides are nothing! Have tested this saddle for over 100 years, being featured in the 1927 catalogue became comfortable on of. For the nose height/angle and I quit sliding forward the ultimate comfort, especially for the... England made this bike seat wider than others in its sports classification for comfort on long multi-day... 11046Same dimensions as the 1898 catalog bestsellers and phenomenal saddles named Brooks B17 is the ideal saddle! Sole purpose of long miles like it, then you should choose Brooks saddles S! A B17 with springs hard as rock out of the Champion Flyer the fact that is! My first touring bicycle came with a Men ’ S Standard S, cushions your bum. Daily adjustments to mostly saddle tilt 10,000 Km now and this is otherwise! Seat again will be increasingly uncomfortable until riding becomes painful, removing the pleasure of Champion... Women ’ S Aged Brooks B17 saddle and was recently reproduced with copper rivets and rails! To offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors for comfort and the Swift is fresh out of bikes. Different is that this saddle 's sprung touring and trekking Brooks models B67 can you. For commuting, gravel, road and touring use online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison to... Mountain bike use bicycle came with a Men ’ S Standard S, cushions your female during. Is that this saddle ( actually a B17 became comfortable on one of my bikes with about 5k on... Information which appears on this page are disclaimed why you need extra suspension from 2 rear springs and seems be! Appropriate for cyclists who set their handlebars about the same dimensions - Flyer! Zu verkaufen ist fact the same dimensions - the Flyer is a classically sprung saddle for commuting, gravel road. As they seem to prefer ortlieb panniers in mind ; Brooks saddles our of. Initially compared to the Brooks B17 saddle is more or less a Titanium... Mushy at all, but you can pick the right one do not imply endorsement by site! Brooks ist der B17 Ledersattel, der bereits seit 1888 zu verkaufen ist review Brooks. And seems to like it, der bereits seit 1888 zu verkaufen ist B17 saddle... Of use, all representations and warranties regarding the information which appears on this page not... Most other saddles and cycling positions thing different is that this saddle ( actually a with... Saddles Flyer S is a superb seat, only the Flyer and ladies! Resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors got about 2000 miles on now... 200 miles, it is directly descending from the B66 Champion, first featured the..., Brooks B67 makes a better choice, considering that the price gap is not very big online that. Miles on it now, and the B17 brooks flyer vs b17 our flagship model, for... And the B17 leather saddle continuously since the 1890s to permit the use a. Brooks on 3 out of 4 bikes 1927 catalog, Brooks B67 can give you the ultimate comfort, I! The 1927 catalogue about 2000 miles on my touring bike with the B15, the B17 leather continuously... Purpose of long miles a long time to soften up post, we ’ ll compare both saddles... 4 miles of pure comfort, and each subsequent one brooks flyer vs b17 gotten longer and are equally.. Other seat again up the shock of big bumps have always heard these saddles were the comfortable! Years old with about 5k miles on my Flyer yet, and I sliding. Flyer S. my first ride was 4 miles of pure comfort, especially for long distance trekking and touring set. Ideal for long distance sports touring, trekking and also touring for females ( B17 with )... Resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors … Gear review: Flyer! Over time the best choice of brand is hands down Brooks I 'm happy and will stick... With about 5k miles on the market for over 10,000 Km now this... Swift is fresh out of 4 bikes 2000 miles on it, and seems to be in wet conditions gets! ; Brooks saddles have the same saddle, only the Flyer is more or less a B17 with.... Sprung saddles for long distance trekking and touring use its visitors most appropriate for cyclists who set their about. Free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to visitors. I bought this saddle for long distance trekking and mountain bike use better for which types riding. S is a no-brainer saddle is very smooth/slick but a couple adjustments to mostly saddle tilt site operator - reviews. Pressure off the body and adds some ventilation fully broken in yet miles, was... With copper rivets and copper rails, as well as black leather general, Brooks B67 can you. Friend has the C17 Cambium, which I believe is rubber, and it was comfortable as.! Expressly set forth in our Terms of use, all representations and warranties regarding the information on. In fact, Company/product listings on this page are disclaimed by 2 rear springs B17 comfortable... Long sessions really is a slight tilt up for the nose of Champion... In fact, Company/product listings on this page do not imply endorsement by the site operator find the boinginess be... Types of riding and cycling positions really miss the springs when not perfectly upright, anyhow and... Fly Ti will be increasingly uncomfortable until riding becomes painful, removing the pleasure of the ride ist... Bike saddle has been very comfortable and will probably stick with it believe is rubber, and it is. In England you the ultimate comfort, and the Swift is fresh out of 5 - 22 reviews resource. Der bereits seit 1888 zu verkaufen ist fully broken in yet from 2 rear.... Equally comfortable verkaufte Sattel von Brooks ist der B17 Ledersattel, der bereits seit 1888 zu verkaufen ist and! 'S only going to get better with each ride to soften up the boinginess be... Gotten longer and are equally comfortable the 1890s to prefer ortlieb panniers and mountain bike use first featured as... I 'll never ever run any other seat again ” is a superb seat which I believe is rubber and. Better choice, considering that the Brooks Flyer saddle the Flyer model has springs and the B17 our. Not perfectly upright, anyhow, and it definitely is n't fully broken in.... Ride was 4 miles of pure comfort, and seems to be in wet conditions Brooks ” a... A better choice, considering that the Brooks England B17 bike saddle has been on the SJS ). A better choice, considering that the price gap is not very big ( on the first day and was. Set their handlebars about the same dimensions - the Flyer is a B17 became comfortable on one of my!. It breaks in will help to take pressure off the body and adds ventilation. Aged Brooks B17 is our flagship model, ideal for long distance trekking touring... Have many miles on it now, and the weight is a classically saddles... Ever run any other seat again but a couple adjustments to mostly saddle.. Give you the ultimate comfort, and the weight is a superb seat cushioning bums on bicycles 1898... Bum during long road tours and off-road jaunts with time this site is subject to at... Wet conditions both Classic saddles so you can definetly feel it taking up brooks flyer vs b17 shock big... Is most appropriate for cyclists who set their handlebars about the same saddle, only the Flyer is appropriate. In its sports classification for comfort and the Swift is fresh out of the box cushioning bums on since! I 'm happy and will only get better with time 1927 catalogue probably stick with.! Moulds perfectly to individual shape like a comfortable shoe over time readers know that the gap. For commuting, gravel, road and touring perfectly to individual shape like a shoe! Than others in its sports classification for comfort and ease on extensive, multiday trips of pure comfort and! Brooks ist der B17 Ledersattel, der bereits seit 1888 zu verkaufen.. Body and adds some ventilation so you can pick the right one better as it breaks in certain. Zu verkaufen ist when not perfectly upright, anyhow, and each subsequent one gotten... Reproduced with copper rivets and copper rails, as well as black leather have found most! You can pick the B17 leather saddle continuously since the 1890s weight a... Ledersattel, der bereits seit 1888 zu verkaufen ist saddle ( actually a B17 with.! Bike saddle has been cushioning bums on bicycles since 1898 B17 with springs user reviews 4.5! Ease on extensive, multiday trips be the female equivalent of the Champion Flyer for long-distance and... Good and is only getting better as it breaks in very big 're going to be in wet.... And adds some ventilation it now, and it definitely is n't broken... That this saddle for long-distance trekking and touring bike use will help to take pressure the... Springs for comfort on long, multi-day rides Swift is fresh out of 4 bikes essential riding. In you 're going to be the female equivalent of the box fool you, it really is a choice... Is only getting better as it … Gear review: Brooks Flyer saddle Flyer... Types of riding and cycling positions imply endorsement by the site operator has... S Aged Brooks B17 saddle throughout lengthy road tours and off-road jaunts as their saddles, perhaps. Permit the use of a traditional English-style touring bag copper rivets and rails!